loader-logo

BIM salad: an approach to BIM implementation

By the CAUPS D1 BIM Commission · coordinated by Arch. Bernardo Bertone · Colegio de Arquitectura y Urbanismo de la Provincia de Santa Fe, Distrito 1

The BIM methodology is a way to achieve greater productivity in the AECO sector (Architecture, Engineering, Construction & Operations), but what does its real implementation involve?

Implementing the methodology is not just a choice of BIM software1, but also involves changes in roles, workflows, communication channels and, above all, in the company's organizational culture.

If we focus on architecture studios and small construction companies in Santa Fe3, the first attempts are usually made without a BIM implementation strategy, since the first approach is to add a BIM software alongside others already in use that are not precisely part of BIM.

This application, without planning and without a study truly rooted in the company's culture, usually turns into what we could call a “BIM salad”, frustrating our first steps in the BIM world. The point we are particularly interested in answering in this article is whether, in this process of adapting the workflow, the exclusive use of BIM software is decisive for the correct implementation of the methodology.

Image 1. Although this image shows the development of BIM from 1980 to the present, we want to show the wide range of solutions created for the construction industry, offering a broad set of resources for an implementation suited to our possibilities and culture. Source:  BIM History Map, BIM development map from 1980 to the present. Version: 05/2021.
https://bigdataconstruction.com/history-of-bim/

Implementing the methodology is not just a choice of BIM software2, but also involves changes in roles, workflows, communication channels and, above all, in the company's organizational culture.

Through the interviews conducted by the CAPSF D1 BIM Commission during 2021, we gathered the views of three BIM experts with different profiles and approaches, who practice independently in Santa Fe, Buenos Aires and Mexico City respectively: architects Alejandro Moreira, Javier Nuñez and Carlos Jiménez Sedano, each with more than 15 years of experience in the field.

Alejandro Moreira states that BIM “(…) is a way of thinking, of building decisions, of working in an integrated, collaborative way; ultimately it is a methodology that involves the entire process of a building, from its ideal manifestation to its real manifestation, as well as all its subsequent operation until that building in some way ceases to exist or is demolished (…) BIM is not a software (…)”4

Javier Nuñez adds in this regard that: “(…) many professionals believe BIM is a software, a software for drawing in 3D (…) [so they are] far from the real concept of BIM (…), [therefore] a lot of outreach and training work is needed for the methodology to start interesting architects, business owners and officials from the different government areas that will implement it (…)”5

The view given by Carlos Jiménez Sedano, does not differ at all from the considerations of Nuñez and Moreira “(…) today I see that [BIM] is not only building information modeling technology, which is what the acronym BIM stands for; today it is a professional opportunity to make our processes better. (…) The revolution in the construction industry began a long time ago; the BIM methodology is one ingredient of it, but the digitalization of this industry is very important (…)” 

Regarding the use of traditional software (CAD) Jiménez states: 

“ (…) CAD is part of the BIM workflow; one does not oppose the other. [However, drawing] two lines and pretending that [is] a wall, and (…) [creating], in a BIM model, a wall that integrates all the characteristics and components of a wall, (…) [are two very different concepts; and this is where] you need technology or software (…) but the model is only one input within BIM; there is also the management that allows the model to be reviewed, coordinated and administered in a different way. So being able to model is very important because it is the simulation, and BIM software is needed to integrate a BIM methodology. You do not need to know how to model to know BIM. (…) many people coordinate, review, quantify, (…) the model is a three-dimensional digital model into which I can integrate information; [on the other hand] it is not that Sketchup is not BIM, it is that the information as such is not typically structured to carry out a quantity takeoff or determine the thermal transmittance of materials. (…). So I believe BIM software has to be aligned with international standards, and that is how we can use it for management, administration or BIM activities. BIM software is needed: for modeling, simulation, data extraction [among other functions] (…) CAD is not enough; it is an input that we will also use for the whole development of digital drawings, (…) CAD is still part of the workflow.”6

Comparative diagram of the traditional workflow and BIM interoperability.
Source: https://biblus.accasoftware.com/es/ifc-que-es-y-relacion-con-el-bim/

Building on these reflections, and reaffirming the idea that implementing the methodology rests on three main pillars, people, technology and processes, we believe that a real step toward keeping up with the global demand for productivity in the AECO industry requires a strategy aligned with the company's organizational culture.

That strategy can be gradual, starting with a core software, so that in an initial stage the workflow may not be entirely covered by BIM software, as long as the trend or final goal is what the methodology implies by definition: the collaborative management of integrated parametric information. 

Perhaps this is a starting point from which many questions will arise, and what matters is facing the new challenge. Implementing the methodology is a process still under development in Santa Fe, and it urgently requires a critical look at our own ways of working in order to adapt to an increasingly competitive and globalized market.

Authors of the article:

Mg. Arch. Bertone, Bernardo
Arch. Cattaneo, Clarisa
Musuruana, Agustín (Architecture student)
Odin, Giovanna (Architecture student)
Arch. Vera, Ramiro

Footnotes:

  1. “The buildingSMART software certification program aims to promote consistent and reliable implementations of buildingSMART standards across multiple software vendors and applications in the global market. Such consistency helps drive faster evaluation, implementation and acceptance of the standard for the exchange and sharing of building information models”
    https://technical.buildingsmart.org/services/certification/
  2. “The buildingSMART software certification program aims to promote consistent and reliable implementations of buildingSMART standards across multiple software vendors and applications in the global market. Such consistency helps drive faster evaluation, implementation and acceptance of the standard for the exchange and sharing of building information models.
    https://technical.buildingsmart.org/services/certification/
  3. Information from the 2020 survey of CAPSF D1 members carried out by the BIM Commission (results published in Revista Origen 2021, CAPSF D1). In most studios and construction companies, implementation happens by adding one or two BIM software packages at best, combined with other non-BIM software (design, budgeting, coordination, construction, maintenance, document management, among others).
  4. Excerpt from the interview with Alejandro Moreira
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6AVqTNXacnc&t=3s
  5. Excerpt from the interview with Javier Nuñez
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhW3TDI9ch0
  6. Excerpt from the interview with Carlos Jiménez
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OPeuIKdJYxo
Interview conducted by the CAUPSF D1 BIM Commission with Arch. Mg. Alejandro Moreira
Interview conducted by the CAUPSF D1 BIM Commission with Arch. Javier Nuñez
Interview conducted by the CAUPSF D1 BIM Commission with Arch. Jiménez Sedano